Release coccinelle-0.2.4

[bpt/coccinelle.git] / parsing_cocci / check_meta.ml

(*
 * Copyright 2010, INRIA, University of Copenhagen
 * Julia Lawall, Rene Rydhof Hansen, Gilles Muller, Nicolas Palix
 * Copyright 2005-2009, Ecole des Mines de Nantes, University of Copenhagen
 * Yoann Padioleau, Julia Lawall, Rene Rydhof Hansen, Henrik Stuart, Gilles Muller, Nicolas Palix
 * This file is part of Coccinelle.
 *
 * Coccinelle is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
 * it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
 * the Free Software Foundation, according to version 2 of the License.
 *
 * Coccinelle is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
 * but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
 * MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
 * GNU General Public License for more details.
 *
 * You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
 * along with Coccinelle.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
 *
 * The authors reserve the right to distribute this or future versions of
 * Coccinelle under other licenses.
 *)


(*
 * Copyright 2010, INRIA, University of Copenhagen
 * Julia Lawall, Rene Rydhof Hansen, Gilles Muller, Nicolas Palix
 * Copyright 2005-2009, Ecole des Mines de Nantes, University of Copenhagen
 * Yoann Padioleau, Julia Lawall, Rene Rydhof Hansen, Henrik Stuart, Gilles Muller, Nicolas Palix
 * This file is part of Coccinelle.
 *
 * Coccinelle is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
 * it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
 * the Free Software Foundation, according to version 2 of the License.
 *
 * Coccinelle is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
 * but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
 * MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
 * GNU General Public License for more details.
 *
 * You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
 * along with Coccinelle.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
 *
 * The authors reserve the right to distribute this or future versions of
 * Coccinelle under other licenses.
 *)


(* For minus fragment, checks that all of the identifier metavariables that
are used are not declared as fresh, and check that all declared variables
are used.  For plus fragment, just check that the variables declared as
fresh are used.  What is the issue about error variables? (don't remember) *)

module Ast0 = Ast0_cocci
module Ast = Ast_cocci
module V0 = Visitor_ast0
module VT0 = Visitor_ast0_types

(* all fresh identifiers *)
let fresh_table = (Hashtbl.create(50) : (Ast.meta_name, unit) Hashtbl.t)

let warning s = Printf.fprintf stderr "warning: %s\n" s

let promote name = (name,(),Ast0.default_info(),(),None,-1)

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)

let find_loop table name =
  let rec loop = function
      [] -> raise Not_found
    | x::xs -> (try Hashtbl.find x name with Not_found -> loop xs) in
  loop table

let check_table table minus (name,_,info,_,_,_) =
  let rl = info.Ast0.pos_info.Ast0.line_start in
  if minus
  then
    (try (find_loop table name) := true
    with
      Not_found ->
	(try
	  Hashtbl.find fresh_table name;
	  let (_,name) = name in
	  failwith
	    (Printf.sprintf
	       "%d: unexpected use of a fresh identifier %s" rl name)
	with Not_found -> ()))
  else (try (find_loop table name) := true with Not_found -> ())

let get_opt fn = Common.do_option fn

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Dots *)

let dots fn d =
  match Ast0.unwrap d with
    Ast0.DOTS(x) -> List.iter fn x
  | Ast0.CIRCLES(x) -> List.iter fn x
  | Ast0.STARS(x) -> List.iter fn x

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Identifier *)

type context = ID | FIELD | FN | GLOBAL

(* heuristic for distinguishing ifdef variables from undeclared metavariables*)
let is_ifdef name =
  String.length name > 2 && String.uppercase name = name

let ident context old_metas table minus i =
  match Ast0.unwrap i with
      Ast0.Id((name,_,info,_,_,_) : string Ast0.mcode) ->
	let rl = info.Ast0.pos_info.Ast0.line_start in
	let is_plus i =
 	  match Ast0.get_mcodekind i with Ast0.PLUS _ -> true | _ -> false in
	let err =
	  if List.exists (function x -> x = name) old_metas
	    && (minus || is_plus i)
	  then
	    begin
	      warning
		(Printf.sprintf
		   "line %d: %s, previously declared as a metavariable, is used as an identifier" rl name);
	      true
	    end
	  else false in
	  (match context with
	       ID ->
		 if not (is_ifdef name) && minus && not err(* warn only once per id *)
		 then
		   warning
		     (Printf.sprintf "line %d: should %s be a metavariable?" rl name)
	     | _ -> ())
    | Ast0.MetaId(name,_,_) -> check_table table minus name
    | Ast0.MetaFunc(name,_,_) -> check_table table minus name
    | Ast0.MetaLocalFunc(name,_,_) -> check_table table minus name
    | Ast0.OptIdent(_) | Ast0.UniqueIdent(_) ->
	failwith "unexpected code"

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Expression *)

let rec expression context old_metas table minus e =
  match Ast0.unwrap e with
    Ast0.Ident(id) ->
      ident context old_metas table minus id
  | Ast0.FunCall(fn,lp,args,rp) ->
      expression FN old_metas table minus fn;
      dots (expression ID old_metas table minus) args
  | Ast0.Assignment(left,op,right,_) ->
      expression context old_metas table minus left;
      expression ID old_metas table minus right
  | Ast0.CondExpr(exp1,why,exp2,colon,exp3) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp1;
      get_opt (expression ID old_metas table minus) exp2;
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp3
  | Ast0.Postfix(exp,op) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.Infix(exp,op) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.Unary(exp,op) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.Binary(left,op,right) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus left;
      expression ID old_metas table minus right
  | Ast0.Paren(lp,exp,rp) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.ArrayAccess(exp1,lb,exp2,rb) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp1;
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp2
  | Ast0.RecordAccess(exp,pt,field) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp;
      ident FIELD old_metas table minus field
  | Ast0.RecordPtAccess(exp,ar,field) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp;
      ident FIELD old_metas table minus field
  | Ast0.Cast(lp,ty,rp,exp) ->
      typeC old_metas table minus ty; expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.SizeOfExpr(szf,exp) -> expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.SizeOfType(szf,lp,ty,rp) -> typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.TypeExp(ty) -> typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.MetaExpr(name,_,Some tys,_,_) ->
      List.iter
	(function x ->
	  match get_type_name x with
	    Some(ty) -> check_table table minus (promote ty)
	  | None -> ())
	tys;
      check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.MetaExpr(name,_,_,_,_) | Ast0.MetaErr(name,_,_) ->
      check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.MetaExprList(name,Ast0.MetaListLen lenname,_) ->
      check_table table minus name;
      check_table table minus lenname
  | Ast0.MetaExprList(name,_,_) ->
      check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.DisjExpr(_,exps,_,_) ->
      List.iter (expression context old_metas table minus) exps
  | Ast0.NestExpr(_,exp_dots,_,w,_) ->
      dots (expression ID old_metas table minus) exp_dots;
      get_opt (expression ID old_metas table minus) w
  | Ast0.Edots(_,Some x) | Ast0.Ecircles(_,Some x) | Ast0.Estars(_,Some x) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus x
  | _ -> () (* no metavariable subterms *)

and get_type_name = function
    Type_cocci.ConstVol(_,ty) | Type_cocci.SignedT(_,Some ty)
  | Type_cocci.Pointer(ty)
  | Type_cocci.FunctionPointer(ty) | Type_cocci.Array(ty) -> get_type_name ty
  | Type_cocci.EnumName(Type_cocci.MV(nm,_,_)) -> Some nm
  | Type_cocci.StructUnionName(_,Type_cocci.MV(nm,_,_)) -> Some nm
  | Type_cocci.MetaType(nm,_,_) -> Some nm
  | _ -> None

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Types *)

and typeC old_metas table minus t =
  match Ast0.unwrap t with
    Ast0.ConstVol(cv,ty) -> typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.Signed(sgn,ty) ->
      get_opt (typeC old_metas table minus) ty
  | Ast0.Pointer(ty,star) -> typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.FunctionPointer(ty,lp1,star,rp1,lp2,params,rp2) ->
      typeC old_metas table minus ty;
      parameter_list old_metas table minus params
  | Ast0.FunctionType(ty,lp1,params,rp1) ->
      get_opt (typeC old_metas table minus) ty;
      parameter_list old_metas table minus params
  | Ast0.Array(ty,lb,size,rb) ->
      typeC old_metas table minus ty;
      get_opt (expression ID old_metas table minus) size
  | Ast0.MetaType(name,_) ->
      check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.DisjType(_,types,_,_) ->
      List.iter (typeC old_metas table minus) types
  | Ast0.EnumName(en,Some id) -> ident GLOBAL old_metas table minus id
  | Ast0.EnumDef(ty,lb,ids,rb) ->
      typeC old_metas table minus ty;
      dots (expression GLOBAL old_metas table minus) ids
  | Ast0.StructUnionName(su,Some id) -> ident GLOBAL old_metas table minus id
  | Ast0.StructUnionDef(ty,lb,decls,rb) ->
      typeC old_metas table minus ty;
      dots (declaration GLOBAL old_metas table minus) decls
  | Ast0.OptType(ty) | Ast0.UniqueType(ty) ->
      failwith "unexpected code"
  | _ -> () (* no metavariable subterms *)

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Variable declaration *)
(* Even if the Cocci program specifies a list of declarations, they are
   split out into multiple declarations of a single variable each. *)

and declaration context old_metas table minus d =
  match Ast0.unwrap d with
    Ast0.MetaDecl(name,_) | Ast0.MetaField(name,_) ->
      check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.Init(stg,ty,id,eq,ini,sem) ->
      (match Ast0.unwrap ini with
	Ast0.InitExpr exp ->
	  typeC old_metas table minus ty;
	  ident context old_metas table minus id;
	  expression ID old_metas table minus exp
      |	_ ->
	  (*
	  if minus
	  then
	    failwith "complex initializer specification not allowed in - code"
	  else*)
	    (typeC old_metas table minus ty;
	     ident context old_metas table minus id;
	     initialiser old_metas table minus ini))
  | Ast0.UnInit(stg,ty,id,sem) ->
      typeC old_metas table minus ty; ident context old_metas table minus id
  | Ast0.MacroDecl(name,lp,args,rp,sem) ->
      ident GLOBAL old_metas table minus name;
      dots (expression ID old_metas table minus) args
  | Ast0.TyDecl(ty,sem) -> typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.Typedef(stg,ty,id,sem) ->
      typeC old_metas table minus ty;
      typeC old_metas table minus id
  | Ast0.DisjDecl(_,decls,_,_) ->
      List.iter (declaration ID old_metas table minus) decls
  | Ast0.Ddots(_,Some x) -> declaration ID old_metas table minus x
  | Ast0.Ddots(_,None) -> ()
  | Ast0.OptDecl(_) | Ast0.UniqueDecl(_) ->
      failwith "unexpected code"

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Initialiser *)

and initialiser old_metas table minus ini =
  match Ast0.unwrap ini with
    Ast0.MetaInit(name,_) ->
      check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.InitExpr(exp) -> expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.InitList(lb,initlist,rb,ordered) ->
      dots (initialiser old_metas table minus) initlist
  | Ast0.InitGccExt(designators,eq,ini) ->
      List.iter (designator old_metas table minus) designators;
      initialiser old_metas table minus ini
  | Ast0.InitGccName(name,eq,ini) ->
      ident FIELD old_metas table minus name;
      initialiser old_metas table minus ini
  | Ast0.Idots(_,Some x) -> initialiser old_metas table minus x
  | Ast0.OptIni(_) | Ast0.UniqueIni(_) ->
      failwith "unexpected code"
  | _ -> () (* no metavariable subterms *)

and designator old_metas table minus = function
    Ast0.DesignatorField(dot,id) ->
      ident FIELD old_metas table minus id
  | Ast0.DesignatorIndex(lb,exp,rb) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.DesignatorRange(lb,min,dots,max,rb) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus min;
      expression ID old_metas table minus max

and initialiser_list old_metas table minus =
  dots (initialiser old_metas table minus)

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Parameter *)

and parameterTypeDef old_metas table minus param =
  match Ast0.unwrap param with
    Ast0.Param(ty,id) ->
      get_opt (ident ID old_metas table minus) id;
      typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.MetaParam(name,_) ->
      check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.MetaParamList(name,Ast0.MetaListLen lenname,_) ->
      check_table table minus name;
      check_table table minus lenname
  | Ast0.MetaParamList(name,_,_) ->
      check_table table minus name
  | _ -> () (* no metavariable subterms *)

and parameter_list old_metas table minus =
  dots (parameterTypeDef old_metas table minus)

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Top-level code *)

and statement old_metas table minus s =
  match Ast0.unwrap s with
    Ast0.Decl(_,decl) -> declaration ID old_metas table minus decl
  | Ast0.Seq(lbrace,body,rbrace) -> dots (statement old_metas table minus) body
  | Ast0.ExprStatement(exp,sem) -> expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.IfThen(iff,lp,exp,rp,branch,_) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp;
      statement old_metas table minus branch
  | Ast0.IfThenElse(iff,lp,exp,rp,branch1,els,branch2,_) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp;
      statement old_metas table minus branch1;
      statement old_metas table minus branch2
  | Ast0.While(wh,lp,exp,rp,body,_) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp;
      statement old_metas table minus body
  | Ast0.Do(d,body,wh,lp,exp,rp,sem) ->
      statement old_metas table minus body;
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.For(fr,lp,exp1,sem1,exp2,sem2,exp3,rp,body,_) ->
      get_opt (expression ID old_metas table minus) exp1;
      get_opt (expression ID old_metas table minus) exp2;
      get_opt (expression ID old_metas table minus) exp3;
      statement old_metas table minus body
  | Ast0.Iterator(nm,lp,args,rp,body,_) ->
      ident GLOBAL old_metas table minus nm;
      dots (expression ID old_metas table minus) args;
      statement old_metas table minus body
  | Ast0.Switch(switch,lp,exp,rp,lb,decls,cases,rb) ->
      expression ID old_metas table minus exp;
      dots (statement old_metas table minus) decls;
      dots (case_line old_metas table minus) cases
  | Ast0.ReturnExpr(ret,exp,sem) -> expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.MetaStmt(name,_) ->     check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.MetaStmtList(name,_) -> check_table table minus name
  | Ast0.Exp(exp) -> expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.TopExp(exp) -> expression ID old_metas table minus exp
  | Ast0.Ty(ty) -> typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.TopInit(init) -> initialiser old_metas table minus init
  | Ast0.Disj(_,rule_elem_dots_list,_,_) ->
      List.iter (dots (statement old_metas table minus)) rule_elem_dots_list
  | Ast0.Nest(_,rule_elem_dots,_,w,_) ->
      dots (statement old_metas table minus) rule_elem_dots;
      List.iter (whencode (dots (statement old_metas table minus))
		   (statement old_metas table minus)
		   (expression ID old_metas table minus))
	w
  | Ast0.Dots(_,x) | Ast0.Circles(_,x) | Ast0.Stars(_,x) ->
      List.iter
	(whencode (dots (statement old_metas table minus))
	   (statement old_metas table minus)
	   (expression ID old_metas table minus)) x
  | Ast0.FunDecl(_,fi,name,lp,params,rp,lbrace,body,rbrace) ->
      ident FN old_metas table minus name;
      List.iter (fninfo old_metas table minus) fi;
      parameter_list old_metas table minus params;
      dots (statement old_metas table minus) body
  | Ast0.Include(inc,s) -> () (* no metavariables possible *)
  | Ast0.Define(def,id,params,body) ->
      ident GLOBAL old_metas table minus id;
      define_parameters old_metas table minus params;
      dots (statement old_metas table minus) body
  | Ast0.Label(i,_) -> ident ID old_metas table minus i
  | Ast0.Goto(_,i,_) -> ident ID old_metas table minus i
  | _ -> () (* no metavariable subterms *)

and define_param old_metas table minus p =
  match Ast0.unwrap p with
    Ast0.DParam(id) -> ident GLOBAL old_metas table minus id
  | Ast0.DPComma(_) | Ast0.DPdots(_) | Ast0.DPcircles(_) ->
      () (* no metavariable subterms *)
  | Ast0.OptDParam(dp)    -> define_param old_metas table minus dp
  | Ast0.UniqueDParam(dp) -> define_param old_metas table minus dp

and define_parameters old_metas table minus x =
  match Ast0.unwrap x with
    Ast0.NoParams -> ()
  | Ast0.DParams(lp,dp,rp) -> dots (define_param old_metas table minus) dp

and fninfo old_metas table minus = function
    Ast0.FStorage(stg) -> ()
  | Ast0.FType(ty) -> typeC old_metas table minus ty
  | Ast0.FInline(inline) -> ()
  | Ast0.FAttr(attr) -> ()

and whencode notfn alwaysfn expression = function
    Ast0.WhenNot a -> notfn a
  | Ast0.WhenAlways a -> alwaysfn a
  | Ast0.WhenModifier(_) -> ()
  | Ast0.WhenNotTrue a -> expression a
  | Ast0.WhenNotFalse a -> expression a

and case_line old_metas table minus c =
  match Ast0.unwrap c with
    Ast0.Default(def,colon,code) ->
      dots (statement old_metas table minus) code
  | Ast0.Case(case,exp,colon,code) ->
      expression GLOBAL old_metas table minus exp;
      dots (statement old_metas table minus) code
  | Ast0.DisjCase(_,case_lines,_,_) ->
      List.iter (case_line old_metas table minus) case_lines
  | Ast0.OptCase(case) -> failwith "unexpected code"

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)
(* Rules *)

let top_level old_metas table minus t =
  match Ast0.unwrap t with
    Ast0.DECL(stmt) -> statement old_metas table minus stmt
  | Ast0.CODE(stmt_dots) -> dots (statement old_metas table minus) stmt_dots
  | Ast0.ERRORWORDS(exps) ->
      List.iter (expression FN old_metas table minus) exps
  | _ -> () (* no metavariables possible *)

let rule old_metas table minus rules =
  List.iter (top_level old_metas table minus) rules

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)

let positions table rules =
  let mcode x =
    match Ast0.get_pos x with
      Ast0.MetaPos(name,constraints,_) ->
	let pos = Ast0.unwrap_mcode name in
	(find_loop table pos) := true
    | _ -> () in
  let option_default = () in
  let bind x y = () in
  let donothing r k e = k e in
  let fn =
    V0.flat_combiner bind option_default
      mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode
      donothing donothing donothing donothing donothing donothing
      donothing donothing donothing donothing donothing donothing donothing
      donothing donothing in

  List.iter fn.VT0.combiner_rec_top_level rules

let dup_positions rules =
  let mcode x =
    match Ast0.get_pos x with
      Ast0.MetaPos(name,constraints,_) ->
	let pos = Ast0.unwrap_mcode name in [pos]
    | _ -> [] in
  let option_default = [] in
  let bind x y = x@y in

  (* Case for everything that has a disj.
     Note, no positions on ( | ) of a disjunction, so no need to recurse on
     these. *)

  let expression r k e =
    match Ast0.unwrap e with
      Ast0.DisjExpr(_,explist,_,_) ->
	List.fold_left Common.union_set option_default
	  (List.map r.VT0.combiner_rec_expression explist)
    | _ -> k e in

  let typeC r k e = (* not sure relevent because "only after iso" *)
    match Ast0.unwrap e with
      Ast0.DisjType(_,types,_,_) ->
	List.fold_left Common.union_set option_default
	  (List.map r.VT0.combiner_rec_typeC types)
    | _ -> k e in

  let declaration r k e =
    match Ast0.unwrap e with
      Ast0.DisjDecl(_,decls,_,_) ->
	List.fold_left Common.union_set option_default
	  (List.map r.VT0.combiner_rec_declaration decls)
    | _ -> k e in

  let statement r k e =
    match Ast0.unwrap e with
      Ast0.Disj(_,stmts,_,_) ->
	List.fold_left Common.union_set option_default
	  (List.map r.VT0.combiner_rec_statement_dots stmts)
    | _ -> k e in

  let donothing r k e = k e in
  let fn =
    V0.flat_combiner bind option_default
      mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode mcode
      donothing donothing donothing donothing donothing donothing
      donothing expression typeC donothing donothing declaration statement
      donothing donothing in

  let res =
    List.sort compare
      (List.fold_left Common.union_set option_default
	 (List.map fn.VT0.combiner_rec_top_level rules)) in
  let rec loop = function
      [] | [_] -> ()
    | ((rule,name) as x)::y::_ when x = y ->
	failwith
	  (Printf.sprintf "duplicate use of %s.%s" rule name)
    | _::xs -> loop xs in
  loop res

(* --------------------------------------------------------------------- *)

let make_table l =
  let table =
    (Hashtbl.create(List.length l) :
       (Ast.meta_name, bool ref) Hashtbl.t) in
  List.iter
    (function x -> Hashtbl.add table (Ast.get_meta_name x) (ref false)) l;
  table

let add_to_fresh_table l =
  List.iter
    (function x ->
      let name = Ast.get_meta_name x in Hashtbl.replace fresh_table name ())
    l

let check_all_marked rname err table after_err =
  Hashtbl.iter
    (function name ->
      function (cell) ->
	if not (!cell)
	then
	  let (_,name) = name in
	  warning
	    (Printf.sprintf "%s: %s %s not used %s" rname err name after_err))
    table

let check_meta rname old_metas inherited_metavars metavars minus plus =
  let old_metas =
    List.map (function (_,x) -> x) (List.map Ast.get_meta_name old_metas) in
  let (fresh,other) =
    List.partition (function Ast.MetaFreshIdDecl(_,_) -> true | _ -> false)
      metavars in
  let (err,other) =
    List.partition (function Ast.MetaErrDecl(_,_) -> true | _ -> false)
      other in
  let (ierr,iother) =
    List.partition (function Ast.MetaErrDecl(_,_) -> true | _ -> false)
      inherited_metavars in
  let fresh_table = make_table fresh in
  let err_table = make_table (err@ierr) in
  let other_table = make_table other in
  let iother_table = make_table iother in
  add_to_fresh_table fresh;
  rule old_metas [iother_table;other_table;err_table] true minus;
  positions [iother_table;other_table] minus;
  dup_positions minus;
  check_all_marked rname "metavariable" other_table "in the - or context code";
  rule old_metas [iother_table;fresh_table;err_table] false plus;
  check_all_marked rname "inherited metavariable" iother_table
    "in the -, +, or context code";
  check_all_marked rname "metavariable" fresh_table "in the + code";
  check_all_marked rname "error metavariable" err_table ""